Small-Batch · Made to Order

The Full
Lineup.

Everything is made fresh Wednesday & Thursday. What you see is what's available this week — nothing more, nothing less.


Cinnamon Rolls

Classic Cinnamon Roll
Quick View
Classic Cinnamon Roll
from $25.00

Pillowy soft hand-rolled dough with cinnamon-y goodness and baked-in caramel flavor; finished with a generous pour of vanilla glaze.

That popular mall cinnamon roll could never!


Classic Cinnamon Roll

Pillowy-soft dough, swirled cinnamon-y goodness, finished with a generous pour of vanilla glaze.

$25 / box of 4

$50 / box 8

Cookie Butter Cinnamon Roll
Quick View
Cookie Butter Cinnamon Roll
from $28.00

Deep, nutty brown butter filling with a caramel drizzle glaze. Richer and more indulgent than the classic — for when you really mean it.

Cookie Butter Cinnamon Roll

The nostalgic cookie butter taste is all throughout this cinnamon roll: in the dough, filling and frosting. Topped with Lotus Biscoff cookie crumbs.

$28 / box of 4

$56 / box of 8

Caramel Pecan Cinnamon Rolls Caramel Pecan Cinnamon Rolls Caramel Pecan Cinnamon Rolls
Quick View
Caramel Pecan Cinnamon Rolls
from $28.00

A deliciously gooey cinnamon roll enrobed in caramel and pecans. Literally, the very BEST thing you will have ever eaten.

Caramel Pecan Cinnamon Roll

A deliciously gooey cinnamon roll enrobed in caramel and pecans. Literally, the very BEST thing you will ever have eaten.

$28 / box of 4

$52 / box of 8

Cookies

3 varieties · Always available

The Best Cookie Ever
$6.00

This brown butter chocolate chip toffee cookie is our favorite. It’s a chewy, delectable, NYC-style cookie where semi-sweet chocolate🤝sweet/salty homemade toffee bits to create the perfect treat!

Best Cookie Ever

Thick, bakery-style chocolate chip cookie with crisp caramelized edges and a gooey center loaded with semi-sweet chips. This brown butter chocolate chip toffee cookie is our favorite. It’s a chewy, delectable, NYC-style cookie where semi-sweet chocolate 🤝🏾 sweet/salty homemade toffee bits to create the perfect treat!

Perfection voted on by the community that keeps coming back for it.

$6 / cookie

Double-Chip Chocolate Chip Cookie Box Double-Chip Chocolate Chip Cookie Box
Quick View
Double-Chip Chocolate Chip Cookie Box
$16.00

Indulge in the ultimate cookie experience with our Double-Chip Chocolate Chip Cookie Box. Packed with twice the chocolatey goodness; with both semi-sweet and dark chocolate pieces, these cookies are a decadent treat perfect for any occasion.

Ideal for gifting to friends and family, or savoring on your own, they deliver a rich and satisfying flavor in every bite.

Double-Chip Chocolate Chip Cookie Box

Our Double-Chip Chocolate Chip Cookie Box is packed with twice the chocolatey goodness; with both semi-sweet and dark chocolate pieces, these mini cookies are a decadent treat perfect for any occasion.

Ideal for gifting to friends and family, or savoring on your own, they deliver a rich and satisfying flavor in every bite.

$16 / ea.

Toasted Pecan Chocolate Chunk Toasted Pecan Chocolate Chunk
Quick View
Toasted Pecan Chocolate Chunk
$6.00

Toasted pieces of pecan pair with chocolate chunks in this delightful cookie.

Toasted Pecan Chocolate Chunk

Toasted pieces of pecan pair with chocolate chunks in this delightful cookie.

$6 / cookie

ROTATING FLAVORS

·

SEASONAL DROPS

·

FOLLOW FOR UPDATES

·

ROTATING FLAVORS · SEASONAL DROPS · FOLLOW FOR UPDATES ·

Seasonal Drops.

Our rotating menu keeps things exciting. Follow us on Instagram to catch new flavors before they sell out — and they always sell out. Our rotating menu keeps things exciting. Follow us on Instagram to catch new flavors before they sell out — and they always sell out.

FOLLOW @BROWNSUGARCOCOABAKESHOP

Seasonal

Rotating · Limited batches

Mini Glazed Lemon Loaf
$16.00

Our take on a popular springtime treat. This pound cake is lemony, not at all dry, and is topped with a lemon glaze for a touch of added sweetness.

Sold in individual pans sized 7’x5“

Glazed Lemon Loaf

Our take on a popular springtime treat. This pound cake is lemony, not at all dry, and is topped with a lemon glaze for a touch of added sweetness.

$20 / loaf

Carrot Cake Cinnamon Roll

Warmly spiced carrot cake flavors rolled into our signature dough and filling, topped with an orange scented frosting. A little nostalgic, a little unexpected.

$25 / box of 4

$52 / box of 8

Mocha Toffee

If you want rich and indulgent, this is it! This dark chocolate cookie has an espresso base and chocolate and toffee pieces mixed in.

Available during WINTER season only!

Something Extra

A piece of Brown Sugar & Cocoa at Home

Vanilla Glaze Vanilla Glaze
Quick View
Vanilla Glaze
$2.95

Ice it up! Choose this for more vanilla sweetness and enjoyment of your cinnamon rolls. 2 oz.

Vanilla Glaze

Ice it up! Choose this for more vanilla glaze sweetness and enjoyment of your cinnamon rolls. (Available in 2 oz. portions)

$2.95 / ea.

What our customers say…

  • "Ordered for the first time for the Love of chocolate chip cookies..

    And these cookies by far surpassed any I’ve ever had! Love at first bite! My tastebuds were literally dancing 💃 The packaging was so sweet and the serving was generous. I could taste the love on each piece. Highly recommend 👌”

    - Tahirah S.

  • "The cookies that the business owner makes are everything you can hope for and more! "

    “You can taste all the ingredients as it melts in your mouth. Real quality ingredients. I absolutely recommend these baked goods to anyone who appreciates desserts done right.”

    - Eli M.

  • "My husband doesn't like cinnamon but he loved the ones from yours!"

    “It's not sweet and she uses conscious ingredients. The cookies is absolutely delicious and my son loves it. Can't wait for more flavors.”

    - Mary R.

  • "The desserts are so delicious!!! 10/10 recommend'

    - Meg G.

  • "Best Christmas gift ever! The cookies were delicious and soft and perfectly made."

    - Lauren T.

  • "loved the service I received from the owner, such a sweet lady. Great sweet treats, My favorite would be the cinnamon rolls."

    - Alycia F.


FAQs

  • We’ve made it easy for you! Every week from Sunday at 12:00 AM to Tuesday at 11:59 PM you can place your order.

    Your order will be fulfilled for Thursday or Friday of the same week. 

  • You can pick-up your order within the time frame set at the time of purchase.

    We also offer delivery as an option, if you are located within Westchester County or The Bronx, for orders totaling $50 or greater.

  • Unfortunately, we do not bake cakes for sale or offer any type of custom order inquires.

  • Interested in wholesale or bulk ordering?

    Email us directly and we will be happy to help.

Ready to order?

Pre-orders open Sunday through Tuesday each week.